|
Track Record
For the Period From January 1, 1997, through November 1, 2002.
Frequently prospective clients ask me, "What is your track record in DMV suspension actions?"
While this is certainly a legitimate question which deserves a straight forward answer, the reality is that there is more than one answer to it. Although the Department of Motor Vehicles has published statistical results over the years which attempt to report in terms of simple "won" or "loss" results, the track record of all those attorneys who regularly practice administrative law [DUI suspension defense] before the department, I have shied away from publishing such statistics - not out of modesty, but because every case turns on detail and a false sense of security can be generated from a particularly "high win" percentage. Nevertheless, to resolve this dilemma, I have listed below all of the DMV cases that I have personally handled since January 1, 1999 [going back to 1964 for statistical data proved impractical, but ask DMV if you're really curious]. You can review my "track record" as a whole and arrive at your own conclusion.
Also, because too often I hear from prospective clients (or worse, from attorneys) the pessimistic view that because a high breath or blood test was obtained, or an accident was involved, or the client is a multiple offender, or they were told by well meaning friends or family that they can't win the criminal case, there is no reason to fight the suspension of their driving privilege. Due to these often unfounded fears (and to give some hope and incentive to those colleagues in the bar who too often give up in the face of DMV adversity), I felt it would also be helpful to list the results of chemical tests obtained in my cases just to show that with competent, dedicated counsel, there is no necessary correlation between the administrative outcome of the case and the chemical test result obtained or any of the other so called "adverse factors".
From left to right
Case Number: indicates our office file number
Underlying Charge: indicates, whenever relevant, the crime for which my client was arrested and which triggered the administrative suspension or revocation of his/her driving privilege;
Hearing: indicates which among the roughly three dozen suspension actions
authorized by statute were initiated by the California Department of Motor Vehicles
[DMV] (the most common of which is the Administrative Per Se [APS] suspension
resulting from the arrest for driving under the influence of alcohol [DUI], but
a variety of other suspension actions have been regularly handled by my office
since 1964, including Negligent Operator revocation actions which are based upon
accidents, serious misdemeanor or felony convictions, or an excessive accumulation
of traffic tickets (each of which are assigned one or more "traffic points") [NEG.OP.];
or those which arise from alleged mental or physical conditions ranging from "old
age" symptoms to habitual drug or alcohol abuse allegations [MEDICAL]; or those
which result from a citable or non-citable single incident such as a vehicular
fatality or serious injury accident [e.g. VC ¤13953];
Offence Location: indicates the location of the DMV Driver Safety Office where the hearing was scheduled or, in the case of an arrest for a felony or misdemeanor DUI which precipitated the suspension action, the location where that arrest occurred;
Chemical Test Results: where a chemical test of blood, breath or urine was obtained, the results of such test as reported to DMV are shown in the fifth column (in the case of an APS [DUI] proceeding predicated on an alleged refusal to select, take or complete such a chemical test, that fact is also shown in this column);
DMV Disposition: shows the final result of my representation in the administrative
proceeding (note: in virtually all APS [DUI] actions, a "stay" or postponement
of the initial suspension is obtained and if/when the suspension order is set
aside, the stay becomes permanent and the incident is retroactively removed from
the department's driving records). The results obtained personally by me for my
clients in each of the 287 DMV cases handled over the past forty-five months are
as follows:
Susp Set Aside indicates that we have "won" the case and the driving privilege has been restored. This can occur before the hearing is actually held through negotiation with the hearing officer assigned or through prehearing motions, or it can happen based upon evidence presented at the administrative hearing, or in some cases, it can occur by administrative appeal, Superior Court intervention by way of writ of mandate, or by a variety of "rehearing" motions before the Driver Safety Office where the hearing was wrongly decided. Also, the suspension/revocation will be set aside if there is an acquittal of the VC ¤23152(b) [driving with a blood alcohol level of .08 grams percent or higher] following trial in the underlying criminal case.
CDL Restored applies to non-DUI cases where the suspension
was set aside, but a period of administrative probation was imposed. This permits
a complete restoration of the client's driving privilege provided he/she does
not suffer any new convictions during the probation period imposed.
Susp Upheld w/Mod CTS During Stay is a phrase which indicates
that the immediate return of the client's driver's license (without any actual
prior suspension period being served) was secured, but that the original APS suspension
order will count as an admin-istrative prior for seven years from the date of
the order.
Susp Upheld indicates that we have "lost" the case and either no appeal was requested by the client or the appeal was taken and the suspension was, nevertheless, upheld.
 |
|
|
|
|
|
Case
Number |
Underlying
Charge |
Hearing |
Offence
Location |
Chemical
Test Results |
DMV
Disposition |
| 97001 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b)w/2 priors |
APS |
Hayward |
Breath .15/.16 |
Susp. Set Aside @ Hrg |
| 97002 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
San Francisco |
Breath .22/.24 |
Susp. Set Aside @ Hrg |
| 97004 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Pleasanton |
Breath .14/.12 |
Susp. upheld |
| 97007 |
VC ¤23152(a) |
APS minor |
Pleasanton |
Breath .07/.06 |
Susp. Set Aside @ Hrg |
| 97011 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Hayward |
Breath .25/.25 |
Susp. Set Aside @ Hrg |
| 97019 |
VC ¤23152(a) |
APS |
Hayward |
Breath .08/.09 |
Susp. Set Aside @ Hrg |
| 97020 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Cupertino |
Breath .18/.18 |
Susp. upheld |
| 97022 |
PC ¤192 [VC ¤13800(a)] |
APS |
Fremont |
N/A |
Susp.
Set Aside on Appeal |
| 97023 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Fremont |
Breath .09/.07 |
Susp. Set Aside @ Pre-Hrg |
| 97024 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Walnut Creek |
Breath .10/.10 |
Susp.
Set Aside on Appeal |
| 97026 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Fremont |
Breath .11/.10 |
Susp. Set Aside @ Hrg |
| 97028 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Fremont |
Blood .13 |
Susp. Set Aside @ Pre-Hrg |
| 97029 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Fremont |
Blood .10 |
Susp. Set Aside @ Hrg |
| 97033 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Lodi |
Blood .20 |
Susp. Set Aside @ Hrg |
| 97035 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b)w/1 prior |
APS |
Fremont |
Breath .16/.16 |
Susp. Set Aside @ Hrg |
| 97037 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Woodland |
Breath .12/.11 |
Susp. Set Aside @ Hrg |
| 97140 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Hayward |
Breath .20/.20 |
Susp. upheld |
| 97041 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b)w/1 prior |
APS |
Oakland |
Breath .12/.11 |
Susp. upheld |
| 97144 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b)w/3 priors |
APS |
Hayward |
Urine .24 |
Susp. Upheld |
| 97146 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS [minor] |
San Jose |
Blood .14 |
Susp. Upheld |
| 97148 |
VC ¤23152(a); VC ¤20002 |
APS |
Fremont |
Refusal |
Susp. Upheld |
| 97150 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Fremont |
Blood .16 |
Susp. Upheld - appeal pending |
| 97152 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Fremont |
Blood .20 |
Susp. Set Aside @ Pre-Hrg |
| 97154 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Fremont |
Blood .22 |
Susp. Set Aside @ Hrg |
| 97159 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Piedmont |
Breath .08/.08 |
Susp. Set Aside @ Hrg |
| 97160 |
None Filed |
APS [minor] |
Newark |
Pas .08 Breath .08/.08 |
APS hrg not yet set by DMV |
| 97161 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Pittsburg |
Breath .16/.17 |
Susp. Set Aside @ Pre-Hrg |
| 98002 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Richmond |
Blood .18 |
Susp. upheld |
| 98004 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) w/1 prior |
APS |
Fremont |
Blood .33 |
Susp. upheld |
| 98010 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Newark |
Blood .16 |
Susp. Set Aside @ Hrg |
| 98012 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Hayward |
Refusal |
Susp. upheld |
| 98014 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Fremont |
Urine .15 |
Susp. Set Aside @ Hrg |
| 98016 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Fremont |
Refusal |
Susp. Set Aside @ Hrg |
| 98018 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Fremont |
Blood .14 |
Susp. Set Aside @ Hrg |
| 98019 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Fremont |
Blood .08 |
Susp. Set Aside @ Hrg |
| 98020 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
San Jose |
Breath .16/.15 |
Susp. Set Aside @ Hrg |
| 98026 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Fremont |
Breath .22/.20 |
Susp. upheld |
| 98028 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Fremont |
Blood .20/Urine .26 |
Susp. Set Aside @ Hrg |
| 98031 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Newark |
Blood .19 |
Susp. upheld |
| 98033 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Fremont |
Refusal |
Susp. Set Aside @ Hrg |
| 98034 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Fremont |
Blood .26 |
Susp. Set Aside @ Pre-Hrg |
| 98046 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Fremont |
Blood .28 |
Susp. Set Aside @ Hrg |
| 98049 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Fremont |
Breath .23/.23 |
Susp. Set Aside @ Hrg |
| 98055 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Hayward |
Breath .11/.10 |
Susp. Set Aside @ Hrg |
| 98056 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Hayward |
Breath .16/.17 |
Susp. Set Aside @ Hrg |
| 98057 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Hayward |
Breath .12/.14 |
Susp. Set Aside @ Hrg |
| 98059 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Hayward |
Urine .13 |
Susp. Set Aside @ Hrg |
| 98062 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Newark |
Blood .08 |
Susp. upheld |
| 98064 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Fremont |
Breath .11/.11 |
Susp.
Set Aside on Appeal |
| 98066 |
none filed |
APS [minor] |
Pleasanton |
Breath .08/.08 |
Susp. Set Aside @ Pre-Hrg |
| 98070 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Hayward |
Breath .17/.17 |
Susp. upheld |
| 98071 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Stockton |
Urine .08 |
Susp. Set Aside @ Pre-Hrg |
| 98072 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
San Jose |
Breath .09/.09 |
Susp. Set Aside @ Hrg |
| 98076 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Walnut Creek |
Urine .16 |
Susp. Set Aside @ Hrg |
| 98078 |
VC ¤12810 |
Neg Op |
Oakland |
N/A |
CDL Restored
- Probation |
| 98080 |
PC ¤192© VC ¤13800(a) |
Neg Op |
Fremont |
N/A |
Susp. upheld |
| 98081 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
San Jose |
Breath .10/.08 |
Susp. Set Aside @ Hrg |
| 98082 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) w/4 priors |
APS |
Vallejo |
Refusal |
Susp. Set Aside @ Hrg |
| 98084 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Fremont |
Blood .10 |
Susp. Set Aside @ Pre-Hrg |
| 98085 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
San Mateo |
Blood .14 |
Susp. Set Aside @ Hrg |
| 98090 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Fremont |
Blood .18 |
Susp. Set Aside @ Hrg |
| 98092 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Martinez |
Urine .11 |
Susp. Set Aside @ Hrg |
| 98094 |
none filed |
APS |
Castro Valley |
Breath .08/.08 |
Susp. Set Aside @ Hrg |
| 98097 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b); VC ¤20002 |
APS |
Fremont |
Blood .18 |
Susp. Set Aside @ Pre-Hrg |
| 98099 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Salinas |
Breath .14/.14 |
Susp. Set Aside @ Hrg |
| 98101 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Fremont |
Blood .10 |
Susp. Set Aside @ Pre-Hrg |
| 98102 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
San Mateo |
Refusal |
Susp. Set Aside @ Hrg |
| 98103 |
VC ¤13953; VC ¤12809 |
medical |
Oakland |
N/A |
withdrawal
of atty |
| 98104 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Fremont |
Blood .23 |
Susp. upheld |
| 98107 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Walnut Creek |
Breath .13/.13 |
Susp. Set Aside @ Hrg |
| 98110 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b)w/1 prior |
APS |
Union City |
Breath .18/.11/.13/.17 - urine .19 |
Susp.
Set aside - acquittal |
| 98112 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) w/2 priors |
APS |
Pleasanton |
Breath .08/.10 |
Susp. Set Aside @ Hrg |
| 98112 |
Concurrent DMV action [VC12809(e)] |
APS |
Oakland |
N/A |
CDL restored
(probation) |
| 98115 |
none filed |
APS |
San Rafael |
Blood N/S - test error |
Susp. Set Aside @ Pre-Hrg |
| 98119 |
[VC ¤12810] |
neg. op. |
Oakland |
N/A |
Susp. Set Aside @ Hrg |
| 98127 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
San Jose |
Blood .13 |
Susp. upheld |
| 98131 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Palo Alto |
Breath .16/.17 |
Susp. upheld |
| 98135 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) w/1 prior |
APS |
San Jose |
Breath .12/.11 |
Susp. Set Aside @ Hrg |
| 98140 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Fremont |
Blood .13 |
Susp. Set Aside @ Hrg |
| 98143 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Oakland |
Breath .22/.22 |
Susp. Set Aside @ Hrg |
| 98146 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Berkeley |
Urine .19-blood .14 |
Susp.
Set aside - acquittal |
| 98148 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Sunnyvale |
Breath .10/.11 |
Susp. Set Aside @ Hrg |
| 98150 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Fremont |
Breath .18/.18 |
Susp. Set Aside @ Hrg |
| 98151 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
San Mateo |
Breath .10/.11 |
Susp. Set Aside @ Hrg |
| 98155 |
VC ¤23152(a) |
APS |
Novato |
Refusal |
Susp. upheld |
| 98156 |
VC ¤23152(a) w/1 prior |
APS |
San Francisco |
Blood .12 |
Susp. upheld |
| 98157 |
none filed |
APS |
Pleasanton |
Breath .08/.08 |
Susp. upheld |
| 98164 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Redwood City |
Blood .14 |
Susp. upheld |
| 98165 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Marin |
Blood .14 |
Susp. Set Aside @ Hrg |
| 98167 |
[VC ¤14252/VC ¤12810] |
Neg Op |
Oakland |
N/A |
DMV PV found - Susp. upheld |
| 98169 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Fremont |
Breath .13/.13 |
Susp. Set Aside @ Hrg |
| 98170 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
San Martin |
Blood .26 |
Susp. Set Aside @ Hrg |
| 98172 |
VC ¤23152(a) |
APS |
Arcata |
Refusal |
Susp. upheld |
| 98177 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) w/1 prior |
APS |
Fremont |
Blood .31 |
Susp. Set Aside @ Hrg |
| 98179 |
VC ¤23152(a) |
APS |
Temecula |
Refusal |
Susp. Set Aside @ Pre-Hrg |
| 98181 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Newark |
Breath .13/.12 |
Susp. Set Aside @ Hrg |
| 98183 |
VC ¤23152(a) |
APS |
Pleasanton |
Breath .08/.09 - Blood .08 |
Susp. upheld |
| 98185 |
VC ¤23152(a) |
APS |
Pleasanton |
Breath .19/.19 |
Susp.
Set aside - acquittal |
| 99003 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Sunnyvale |
Blood .16 |
Susp. Set Aside @ Hrg |
| 99006 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Fremont |
Breath .18/def refusal |
Susp. Set Aside @ Hrg |
| 99007 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Dublin |
Blood .13 |
Susp.
set aside - acquittal |
| 99010 |
[VC ¤13953] |
medical |
Oakland |
N/A |
CDL restored w/o restriction |
| 99011 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Fremont |
Breath .19 |
Susp. Set Aside @ Hrg |
| 99013 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Fairfax |
Breath .16/.14 |
susp upheld |
| 99019 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
San Jose |
Breath .19/.18 |
Susp. Set Aside @ Hrg |
| 99021 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Fremont |
Breath .12/.11 |
Susp.
Set aside - acquittal |
| 99023 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Sunnyvale |
Breath .17/.16 |
susp upheld |
| 99024 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
San Jose |
Blood .13 |
susp upheld |
| 99027 |
VC ¤23152(a) |
APS |
Redwood City |
Breath .14/.14 Blood .13 |
susp upheld |
| 99029 |
VC ¤23152 |
APS |
San Jose |
Breath .11/.11 |
susp upheld |
| 99030 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
San Jose |
Breath .14/.14 |
susp upheld |
| 99032 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Oakland |
Breath .13/.14 |
Susp. Set
aside - acquittal |
| 99035 |
[VC ¤13953] |
medical |
Oakland |
N/A |
CDL retored
w/o restriction |
| 99038 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
San Mateo |
Breath .09/.08 |
susp upheld |
| 99039 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Oakland |
Breath .20/.19 |
Susp. Set Aside @ Hrg |
| 99040 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Sunnyvale |
Blood .29 |
susp upheld |
| 99042 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Castro Valley |
Breath .20/.20 |
susp upheld |
| 99043 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Fremont |
Urine .09 |
susp upheld - appeal pending |
| 99045 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
San Jose |
Blood .25 |
susp upheld |
| 99047 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) w/1 prior |
APS |
Fremont |
Blood .19 |
Susp.
Set aside - acquittal |
| 99048 |
None Filed |
APS |
Castro Valley |
Breath .09/.08 |
Awaiting aps re-hrg |
| 99049 |
[VC ¤13953] |
medical |
Oakland |
N/A |
CDL restored
(probation) |
| 99052 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Burlingame |
Breath .12/.12 |
susp upheld - restricted class
a license issued |
| 99055 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Hillsdale |
Breath .10/.10 |
Susp. Set Aside @ Hrg |
| 99058 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Fremont |
Breath .22/.21 |
Susp. Set Aside @ Hrg |
| 99061 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
San Francisco |
Refusal |
Susp. Set Aside @ Hrg |
| 99063 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Union City |
Breath .12/.12 |
Susp. Set Aside @ Hrg |
| 99065 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
San Jose |
Breath .21/.20 |
Susp. upheld |
| 99068 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Union City |
Refusal |
Susp. Set Aside @ Hrg |
| 99071 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Fremont |
Blood .29 |
Susp. Set Aside @ Hrg |
| 99073 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Newark |
Breath .16/.16 |
Susp. Set Aside @ Hrg |
| 99074 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Sunnyvale |
Breath .12/.11 |
Susp. Set Aside @ Hrg |
| 99076 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Fremont |
Blood .15 |
Awaiting aps re-hrg |
| 99077 |
VC ¤23152(a) |
APS |
Kingsburg |
Refusal |
awaiting aps hrg |
| 99078 |
VC ¤23152(a) |
APS |
Oakland |
Blood .26 |
Susp. Set Aside @ Hrg |
| 99080 |
VC ¤23152(a) |
APS |
Hollister |
Breath .09/.10 |
Susp. Set Aside @ Hrg |
| 99082 |
VC ¤23152(a) |
APS |
Sacramento |
N/A |
Susp. upheld |
| 99087 |
VC ¤23152(a) |
APS |
San Jose |
Refusal |
Susp. Set Aside @ Hrg |
| 99089 |
VC ¤23152(a) |
APS |
Fremont |
Refusal |
Susp. upheld |
| 99090 |
VC ¤23152(a) |
APS |
Fremont |
Refusal |
Susp. upheld |
| 99094 |
VC ¤23152(a) |
APS |
San Francisco |
Refusal |
Susp. upheld |
| 99097 |
VC ¤23152(a) |
APS |
Fremont |
Refusal |
Susp. Set Aside @ Hrg |
| 99098 |
VC ¤23152(a) |
APS |
Castro Valley |
Refusal |
Susp. Set Aside @ Hrg |
| 99100 |
VC ¤23152(a) |
APS |
Hayward |
Refusal |
Susp. Set Aside @ Hrg |
| 99101 |
VC ¤23152(a) |
APS |
Fremont |
Refusal |
Susp. upheld |
| 99103 |
VC ¤23152(a) |
APS |
San Francisco |
Refusal |
Susp. upheld |
| 99104 |
VC ¤23152(a) |
APS |
San Francisco |
Refusal |
Susp. upheld |
| 99109 |
VC ¤23152(a) |
APS |
San Jose |
Refusal |
Susp. Set Aside @ Hrg |
| 99112 |
VC ¤23152(a) |
APS |
San Francisco |
Refusal |
Susp. upheld |
| 99115 |
VC ¤23152(a) |
APS |
San Jose |
Refusal |
Susp. upheld |
| 99115 |
VC ¤23152(a) |
APS |
San Jose |
Refusal |
Susp. Set Aside @ Hrg |
| 99117 |
VC ¤23152(a) |
APS |
Fremont |
Refusal |
Susp. Set Aside @ Pre-Hrg |
| 99119 |
VC ¤23152(a) |
APS |
Fremont |
Refusal |
Susp. Set Aside @ Hrg |
| 99120 |
VC ¤23152(a) |
APS |
San Jose |
Refusal |
Susp. upheld |
| 99125 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Alameda |
Breath .18/.18 |
Susp. upheld |
| 99127 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Sunnyvale |
Blood .10 |
Awaiting APS H.O. decision |
| 99130 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Berkeley |
Breath .15/.14 |
Susp. Set Aside @ Hrg |
| 99131 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Oakland |
Breath .15/.14 |
Susp. Set Aside @ Pre-Hrg |
| 99132 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
San Francisco |
Breath .10/.10 |
Susp. Set Aside @ Hrg |
| 99135 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Concord |
Breath .15/.14 |
Awaiting APS hrg |
| 99142 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Hayward |
Breath .15/.13 |
Awaiting APS re-hrg |
| 99143 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Fremont |
Blood .19 |
Susp. Mod. CTS During Stay |
| 00001 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Pleasanton |
Breath .14/.13 |
Susp. upheld |
| 00005 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Fremont |
Blood .20 |
Awaiting APS hrg |
| 00010 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
San Francisco |
Breath .09 |
Awaiting APS re-hrg |
| 00017 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Fremont |
Breath .21 |
Susp. upheld |
| 00019 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Irvine |
Breath .21 |
Awaiting APS hrg |
| 00022 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Fremont |
Breath .19/.18 |
Susp. upheld |
| 00024 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Newark |
Breath .10/.10 |
Awaiting APS hrg |
| 00025 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Walnut Creek |
Refusal |
Awaiting APS hrg |
| 00027 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Fremont |
Breath .10/.13/.13 |
Susp. upheld |
| 00029 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Oakland |
Breath .14/.14 |
Awaiting APS hrg |
| 00031 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Hayward |
Breath .13/.11 |
Awaiting APS H.O. Decision |
| 00033 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
San Jose |
Breath .18/.18 |
Awaiting APS hrg |
| 00035 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Fremont |
Breath .14/.14 |
Susp. upheld |
| 00038 |
Challenge to IN |
APS |
Oakland |
Breath .08/.08 |
Rqst to Pro Per Hrg Reopen Hrg
Denied |
| 00040 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Fremont |
Blood .19 |
Susp. Mod. CTS During Appeal |
| 00047 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Newark |
Refusal |
Awaiting APS hrg |
| 00048 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Livermore |
Breath .12/.12 |
Awaiting APS hrg |
| 00049 |
VC ¤13953 |
Medical |
Sacramento |
N/A |
Awaiting APS hrg |
| 00052 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Fremont |
Blood .21 |
Awaiting APS hrg |
| 00054 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
San Mateo |
Breath .22/.22 |
Susp. upheld |
| 00057 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Walnut Creek |
Breath .13/.13 |
Susp. Set Aside @ Hrg |
| 00061 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Newark |
Refusal |
Susp. upheld |
| 00062 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Union City |
Breath .27/.29 |
Susp. Set Aside @ Pre-Hrg |
| 00063 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Woodside |
Refusal |
Susp. Set Aside @ Hrg |
| 00065 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Union City |
Blood .09 |
Susp. Set Aside @ Pre-Hrg |
| 00068 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Fremont |
Blood .28 |
Susp. upheld |
| 00069 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Pacific Grove |
Refusal |
Susp. upheld |
| 00070 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS minor |
Pleasant Hill |
Breath .O8/.07 |
Susp. Set Aside @ Pre-Hrg |
| 00072 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
San Ramon |
Breath .16/.16 |
Susp. Set Aside @ Hrg |
| 00073 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS minor |
Santa Clara |
Blood .21 |
Susp. upheld |
| 00074 |
VC ¤23152(a) |
APS |
Fremont |
Breath .11/.10 |
Susp. upheld |
| 00077 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS minor |
Snata Clara |
Blood .11 |
Susp. upheld |
| 00078 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Fremont |
Breath .11/.12 |
Susp. upheld |
| 00080 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS minor |
San Jose |
Blood .21 |
Susp. upheld |
| 00081 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
San Ramon Hayward |
Breath .16/.16 |
Susp. Set Aside - Acquittal |
| 01002 |
Challenge to IN pro per hrg |
APS |
Oakland |
N/A |
Rqst to reopen hrg granted |
| 01002 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Oakland |
Breath .08/.08 |
Susp. upheld |
| 01003 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
San Francisco |
Refusal |
Susp. Set Aside @ Hrg |
| 01005 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Sunnyvale |
Breath .11/.11 |
Susp. upheld |
| 01006 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Los Gatos |
Breath .08/.09 |
Susp. Set Aside @ Hrg |
| 01008 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
San Jose |
Breath .13/.14 |
Susp. upheld |
| 01009 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Fremont |
Breath .12/.12 |
Susp. Set Aside @ Hrg |
| 01010 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Danville |
Blood .14 |
Susp. Set Aside @ Hrg |
| 01011 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Napa |
Breath .17/.18 |
Susp. Set Aside @ Hrg |
| 01012 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Burlingame |
Breath .09/.10 |
Susp. Set Aside @ Hrg |
| 01014 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Castro Valley |
Breath .11/.17/.15 |
Susp.
Set Aside - Acquittal |
| 01016 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Redwood City |
Breath .18/.18 |
Susp. Mod. CTS During Stay |
| 01017 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Mountain View |
Breath .13/.14 |
Susp. Mod. CTS During Stay |
| 01019 |
None |
APS
minor |
El Segundo |
Pas.02/.02 |
Susp. Set Aside @ Hrg |
| 01021 |
VC ¤14103 petition |
APS |
Sacramento |
N/A |
Rqst to reopen hrg granted |
| 01021 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Woodland |
Blood.24 |
Susp. Set Aside @ Hrg |
| 01022 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Sacramento |
Breath .17/.17 |
Susp. Set Aside @ Hrg |
| 01023 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Oakland |
Refusal |
Susp. Set Aside @ Hrg |
| 01025 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Oakland |
Refusal |
Susp. upheld |
| 01026 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Fremont |
Blood .10 |
Susp. Set Aside @ Hrg |
| 01027 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Pleasanton |
Blood .10 |
Susp. Set Aside @ Hrg |
| 01028 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Fremont |
Blood .15 |
Susp. upheld |
| 01029 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Lafayette |
Blood .15 |
Susp. Set Aside @ Hrg |
| 01031 |
VC ¤23152(a) w/2 priors |
APS |
Union City |
refusal |
Susp. Set Aside @ Hrg |
| 01032 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Manhattan Beach |
Blood .12 |
Susp. Set Aside @ Hrg |
| 01033 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Hayward |
Blood .17 |
Susp. upheld |
| 02001 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
San Francisco |
Breath .17/.14/.16 |
Susp. upheld |
| 02002 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Fremont |
Blood .10 |
Susp. Set Aside @ Hrg |
| 02003 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Oakland |
Breath .10/.10 |
Susp. upheld |
| 02004 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Tahoe City |
Breath .13/.12 |
Susp. Set Aside @ Hrg |
| 02005 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Fremont |
Refusal |
Susp. Set Aside @ Hrg |
| 02006 |
VC ¤13953/13954 |
APS |
Northridge |
N/A |
Susp. Set Aside @ Hrg |
| 02007 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
San Fransico |
Breath .10/.09 |
Susp. Set Aside @ Hrg |
| 02008 |
VC ¤13953/13954 |
APS |
Davis |
Blood .24 |
Susp. Set Aside @ Hrg |
| 02009 |
None Filed |
APS minor |
Hayward |
Breath .07/08 |
Susp. upheld |
| 02011 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Fremont |
Blood .21 |
Susp. Set Aside @ Hrg |
| 02013 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Hayward |
Blood .19 |
Susp. upheld |
| 02014 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Pleasanton |
Blood .20 |
Susp. Set Aside @ Hrg |
| 02016 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) w/2 priors |
APS |
Fremont |
Blood .22 |
Awaiting hearing |
| 02017 |
Challenge to IN pro per hrg |
medical |
Oakland |
N/A |
Rqst to reopen hrg granted |
| 02017 |
VC ¤13953;VC 12809 |
medical |
Livermore |
N/A |
Awaiting Rehearing |
| 02018 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Dublin |
Breath .09/.08 |
Susp. Set Aside @ Hrg |
| 02019 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Pleasanton |
Breath .19/.18 |
Susp. Set Aside @ Hrg |
| 02019 |
VC ¤23152(a)(b) |
APS |
Pleasanton |
Breath .19/.18 |
Susp. Set Aside @ Hrg |
| 02020 |
Correct DMV |
N/A |
Sacramento |
N/A |
DMV Records Corrected |
|
